What is the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 and who can apply?

The Act gives the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency, set out in Schedule 1, the force of law. If it is inconsistent with the Corporations Act or the Bankruptcy Act, the Model Law prevails (ss 21 and 22).

The applicant is the “foreign representative”. That is a person or body authorised in a foreign proceeding to administer the reorganisation or liquidation of the debtor’s assets (art 2). Liquidators, administrators and bankruptcy trustees qualify, as does a Chapter 11 debtor in possession: Moore v Australian Equity Investors [2012] FCA 1002.

Section 10 nominates the Federal Court and the State and Territory Supreme Courts for companies, and the Federal Court alone for individuals.

What is the difference between a foreign main and non-main proceeding?

A foreign main proceeding takes place where the debtor has its COMI. A non-main proceeding takes place where the debtor merely has an “establishment” (art 2).

Article 16(3) presumes that a company’s COMI is its registered office, and an individual’s is their habitual residence. The presumption can be rebutted by factors that are objective and ascertainable by third parties: Akers v Saad Investments Co Ltd [2010] FCA 1221.

In Kapila, in the matter of Edelsten [2014] FCA 1112, the debtor lived in Victoria. His Florida bankruptcy was recognised only as a non-main proceeding, but the court still appointed an Australian representative to administer local assets.

What does recognition give a foreign representative?

Automatic stay (art 20). On recognition of a foreign main proceeding, individual actions and execution against the debtor’s assets are stayed. The debtor’s right to transfer or encumber assets is suspended. Under s 16 of the Act, the stay has the same scope and exceptions as an Australian liquidation or bankruptcy stay. Secured creditors keep their rights.

Discretionary relief (arts 19 and 21). For main or non-main proceedings, the court may stay proceedings and suspend dealings with assets. It may order examinations and production of documents, and entrust Australian assets to the foreign representative. Interim relief is available from filing (art 19), and a recognised representative may bring voidable transaction claims (art 23).

Protection of local creditors (art 22). Before assets are distributed to the foreign representative, the court must be satisfied that Australian creditors are adequately protected (art 21(2)). In Akers v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2014] FCAFC 57, Cayman Islands liquidators of Saad Investments proposed to remit all Australian assets. The Full Federal Court upheld orders letting the ATO first recover its proportionate share.

What must be filed, and how long does recognition take?

Article 15 requires:

  • a certified copy of the decision commencing the foreign proceeding and appointing the foreign representative, or a certificate from the foreign court
  • a statement identifying all known foreign proceedings concerning the debtor and, under s 13, any Australian insolvency proceedings
  • an affidavit from the foreign representative verifying those documents and the facts supporting COMI
  • English translations where needed (art 15(4)).

Part 15A of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 requires published notice of the filing (Form 20) and of any order made (Form 21). Section 14 imposes a continuing duty to report changes to the foreign proceeding or any new proceedings. The Supreme Court of Queensland has equivalent rules.

The court must decide the application “at the earliest possible time” (art 17(3)). A well-documented, uncontested application is often determined within a few months.

How do cooperation, concurrent proceedings and letters of request work?

Australian courts and office holders must cooperate “to the maximum extent possible” with foreign courts and representatives (arts 25 to 27). Where an Australian liquidation or bankruptcy also exists, relief must be consistent with it and no creditor may be paid twice (arts 28 to 32).

The older mechanisms survive. Under s 581 of the Corporations Act, an Australian court must act in aid of a court of a prescribed country. Those countries include New Zealand, Singapore, Malaysia, the United Kingdom, the United States and Canada. The court may aid any other foreign court. Each request comes by letter of request from the foreign court. Section 29 of the Bankruptcy Act is the personal insolvency equivalent. In Re Chow Cho Poon (Private) Ltd [2011] NSWSC 300, the Supreme Court of New South Wales assisted Singapore liquidators. It explained how s 581 sits alongside the Model Law.

What should you do if you are a foreign representative with Australian assets?

  1. Identify the Australian assets, claims and any proceedings already on foot against the debtor.
  2. Check whether an Australian liquidator, administrator or trustee has been appointed.
  3. Gather evidence of COMI and certified copies of the appointment order, with translations.
  4. Decide between recognition and a letter of request, and whether interim relief is needed.
  5. Instruct Australian lawyers to prepare the originating process, affidavits and notices.

How Taylor David can help

We act for foreign liquidators, administrators, trustees in bankruptcy and their lawyers, and for Australian creditors affected by foreign proceedings. We advise only on Australian law and Australian-based matters. We can:

  • advise whether the proceeding is likely to be recognised as main or non-main
  • prepare and file the recognition application in the Federal Court or the Supreme Court of Queensland
  • seek interim relief, examinations and orders to realise or remit Australian assets
  • pursue liquidator claims and debt recovery for a foreign estate.

This work sits within our insolvency and litigation practices.